Wednesday, October 26, 2011

TEST 1 Answers

Please read over my example answers to the exam and compare them to your own, especially the short answer questions. If you still have any questions you can see me in my office hours (FRI 9:30am-10:30am) or email me to set up an appointment.


Test #1 Answer Key:

True/False:
  1. False
  2. True
  3. False
  4. False
  5. False
  6. False
  7. True
  8. False
  9. True

Multiple Choice:
  1. c
  2. b
  3. a
  4. b
  5. c
  6. a
  7. d
Short Answer:

  1. Trust in the government has gone down for numerous reasons including economic difficulties, dissatisfaction with the government and disapproval of Obama's healthcare bill. One can also point to the fact that in the 50s there was a lot of economic prosperity and trust in the government due to having won WWII. After the 50s wars like the Vietnam War, which was very unpopular, decreased trust in the government.

  2. The two ways to interpret the 2nd amendment are as a “collective” right and as an “individual” right. The collective right interpretation means that owning a gun is only a right for those involved in a militia. The individual right interpretation means that owning a gun is a right for all people.

  3. The three reasons why it was predicted that Democrats might lose a lot of seats in 2010 were that a. the Democrats held a lot of seats in Republican leaning districts, b. in mid-term elections voters tend to vote for the party that is not in power, and c. there is general dissatisfaction with the Democrats who were in power.

  4. THIS QUESTION IS VERY OPEN ENDED WHICH MEANS I ACCEPTED A LOT OF DIFFERENT ANSWERS. THIS IS A LIST OF POSSIBLE ANSWERS: The political atmosphere in the US is very tense right now because the political parties are not cooperating, Obama's government is very partisan, the healthcare bill is unpopular, the economic crisis is making everyone nervous, there is distrust in the government, and there is a new trend of people who want a smaller government (the Tea Party).

Friday, October 14, 2011

Week 7 Reading


Please read this article closely for next week. This means that you read it at least one time, take notes and look up words or concepts that you do not understand. You MUST bring the article with you to class and have done the reading. 
You DO NOT have to write a summary; however, if you come to class and have not done the reading you WILL be asked to leave and I will ask your name so I can mark you as absent.
If you are on your computer or are talking in class you WILL be asked to leave.
June 3, 2011 2:57 PM , From CBS
WASHINGTON - The Republican-controlled House on Friday adopted a resolution rebuking President Barack Obama for dispatching U.S. military forces against Libya without congressional approval. The vote was 268-145, over White House objections.

The resolution by Speaker John Boehner said the president has failed to provide a "compelling rationale" for the nearly 3-month old operation to aid rebels battling Moammar Gadhafi's forces. During Friday's debate, Democrats and Republicans complained that Obama ignored Congress' constitutional authority to declare war. The nonbinding measure insists that Obama provide Congress with details on the scope of the mission and its costs within 14 days. It also bars U.S. ground forces except to rescue an American service member.

Shortly after adopting the resolution, the House rejected a considerably tougher measure advanced by Rep. Dennis Kucinch that demanded an end to U.S. involvement in the NATO-led operation in Libya. The vote was 265-148. The GOP leadership hastily pulled together the Boehner resolution amid concerns in both parties that the Kucinich measure was gaining ground.

The Senate had no plans to consider the measure, which would allow the U.S. to continue to remain engaged in the mission and would have no impact on the logistical and intelligence support the Americans have been providing.

Boehner assailed the administration for failing to answer several questions about the operation. "Today's debate on Libya is the first step and clearly there's information that we want from the administration that we asked for in this resolution and it's information that we expect to get," the Ohio Republican told reporters. "But there isn't any question in my mind that Congress is going to take further action in the weeks to come."

The White House pushed back against both resolutions, with spokesman Josh Earnest calling them "unnecessary and unhelpful." Earnest insisted that the administration has been consulting with Congress since before Obama ordered air strikes. "It is the view of this administration that we've acted in accordance with the war powers act because of these regular consultations," Earnest said aboard Air Force One en route to Toledo, Ohio.

But lawmakers faulted the commander in chief for ignoring both Congress' constitutional authority to declare war and the 1973 War Powers Resolution that requires congressional authorization within 60 days of military action. That deadline expired last month. "Shall the president, like the King of England, be a dictator on foreign policy?" asked Rep. Jerrold Nadler, D-N.Y. "The authors of the Constitution said we don't trust kings."

Republicans and Democrats have been frustrated with Obama's treatment of Congress, particularly the level of consultation and details on the scope of the Libyan mission and its costs. "What did he do, send a tweet to the chairman of the Armed Services and Intelligence committees?" Rep. Phil Gingrey, R-Ga., asked mockingly.

Obama ordered air strikes in March to back Libyan rebels battling Gadhafi's regime after limited consultation with Congress. More recently, the United States has operated in a support role as the standoff continues between Gadhafi's forces and the rebels.

The president has argued that he acted to prevent a massacre in the rebel stronghold of Benghazi, and he had the backing of several lawmakers, including Sen. John McCain of Arizona, the ranking Republican on the Armed Services Committee.

Initially, the military operation was largely constituted of U.S., British and French naval and air attacks, with the United States taking the lead. NATO took charge at the end of March and U.S. forces now play a support role that includes aerial refueling of NATO warplanes and intelligence, and surveillance and reconnaissance work. The U.S. also flies unmanned drones over Libya.

Obama said when he ordered U.S. forces to support the mission that there would be no American ground troops. Although no U.S. military forces are present, The Associated Press and other news organizations have reported that the CIA has paramilitary officers operating alongside rebel forces in the North African nation.
Source: http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2011/06/03/politics/main20068733.shtml

Wednesday, October 5, 2011

Week 6 Reading and Assignment


Please read the following article for your 6th class day and write a summary of approximately 10 sentences. From now on I want your summaries typed and printed double spaced. Thanks. -Megan
 
From The Washington Post
By Randy E. Barnett
Sunday, March 21, 2010
With the House set to vote on health-care legislation, the congressional debate on the issue seems to be nearing its conclusion. But if the bill does become law, the battle over federal control of health care will inevitably shift to the courts. Virginia's attorney general, Ken Cuccinelli II, has said he will file a legal challenge to the bill, arguing in a column this month that reform legislation "violate[s] the plain text of both the Ninth and Tenth Amendments." On Friday, South Carolina Attorney General Henry McMaster and Florida Attorney General Bill McCollum announced that they will file a federal lawsuit if health-care reform legislation passes.  Will these cases get anywhere? Here is a guide to the possible legal challenges to a comprehensive health-care bill.
The individual mandate.
Can Congress really require that every person purchase health insurance from a private company or face a penalty? The answer lies in the commerce clause of the Constitution, which grants Congress the power "to regulate commerce . . . among the several states." Historically, insurance contracts were not considered commerce, which referred to trade and carriage of merchandise. That's why insurance has traditionally been regulated by states. But the Supreme Court has long allowed Congress to regulate and prohibit all sorts of "economic" activities that are not, strictly speaking, commerce. The key is that those activities substantially affect interstate commerce, and that's how the court would probably view the regulation of health insurance.
But the individual mandate extends the commerce clause's power beyond economic activity, to economic inactivity. That is unprecedented. While Congress has used its taxing power to fund Social Security and Medicare, never before has it used its commerce power to mandate that an individual person engage in an economic transaction with a private company. Regulating the auto industry or paying "cash for clunkers" is one thing; making everyone buy a Chevy is quite another. Even during World War II, the federal government did not mandate that individual citizens purchase war bonds.
If you choose to drive a car, then maybe you can be made to buy insurance against the possibility of inflicting harm on others. But making you buy insurance merely because you are alive is a claim of power from which many Americans instinctively shrink. Senate Republicans made this objection, and it was defeated on a party-line vote, but it will return.
The Cornhusker Kickback, the Louisiana Purchase, Gator Aid and other deals.
Some states are threatening lawsuits to block the special deals brokered by individual senators in exchange for their votes. Unless the reconciliation bill passes the Senate, such deals could remain in place. Article I of the Constitution allows Congress to tax and spend to "provide for the common defense and general welfare of the United States." Normally, this is no barrier to legislation benefiting a particular state or city. Congress can always argue that, say, an Air Force base in Nebraska benefits the United States as a whole. But the deals in the Senate bill are different. It is really hard to identify a benefit to all the states from exempting one state from an increase in Medicare costs or allowing only the citizens of Florida to get Medicare Advantage.
The Slaughter House rule.
A far graver threat to the bill would have been to declare it unconstitutional because it was never formally voted on by the House and therefore never became law. Article I requires that every bill "shall have passed the House of Representatives and the Senate" to become law, and that "the votes of both houses shall be determined by yeas and nays, and the names of the persons voting for and against the bill shall be entered in the journal of each House respectively."
The whole purpose of the "deem and pass" procedure -- which was advocated by Rules Committee Chairman Louise Slaughter -- was to avoid a separate vote on the Senate bill, which many House members find objectionable, and instead vote on the reconciliation bill and simultaneously "deem" the Senate measure passed. Although Democrats cited prior examples of deem and pass, "the Republicans did it" is not a recognized constitutional argument -- especially if the public and the justices have never heard of such a thing. This constitutional objection seems to have succeeded, as House leaders decided on Saturday to take a separate vote on the Senate version, rather than "deeming" it passed.
State sovereignty provisions.
Several states are considering measures attempting to exempt their residents from an individual health insurance mandate. While such provisions may have a political impact, none is likely to have any effect on the legislation's constitutionality. Under the 10th Amendment, if Congress enacts a law pursuant to one of the "powers . . . delegated to the United States by the Constitution," then that law is supreme, and nothing a state can do changes this. Any state power to "nullify" unconstitutional federal laws has long been rejected.

Constitutional amendments.
Of course, there is one additional way for states to win a fight about the constitutionality of health-care legislation: Make it unconstitutional. Article V of the Constitution gives state legislatures the power to require Congress to convene a convention to propose an amendment to the Constitution. If three-fourths of the state legislatures demand an amendment barring the federal regulation of health insurance or an individual mandate, Congress would be constitutionally bound to hold a convention. Something like this happened in 1933 when Congress proposed and three-quarters of the states ratified the 21st Amendment, removing from the Constitution the federal power to prohibit the manufacture, sale and transportation of alcohol. But the very threat of an amendment convention would probably induce Congress to repeal the bill.
Ultimately, there are three ways to think about whether a law is constitutional: Does it conflict with what the Constitution says? Does it conflict with what the Supreme Court has said? Will five justices accept a particular argument?
Randy E. Barnett teaches constitutional law at Georgetown University. He is the author of "Restoring the Lost Constitution: The Presumption of Liberty."
Source: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/03/19/AR2010031901470.html

Sunday, October 2, 2011

Discussion Questions for Weeks 2, 3, & 4


US Civilization—US Political Institutions and Society
Week 2
Discussion Questions
Majority of Americans Distrust the Government

1.     When was the first time that the “trust” question was asked to Americans?
2.     Why do you think it has declined since then? Why do you think it was high in the 50s?
3.     Why does the article say there is distrust now?
4.     Are Americans angry with the government or are they frustrated?
5.     In what ways can the government threaten personal freedom?
6.     Why would the healthcare bill make people more distrustful of the government?
7.     Do you distrust the French government? Why or why not?
US Civilization—US Political Institutions and Society

Week 3
Discussion Questions
Gun Control
2nd Amendment:
"A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed."

1.     Who was president when a federal law was passed requiring background checks for gun purchases? (Bill Clinton)
2.     Is George Bush, or Al Gore “anti-gun”? (Al Gore)
3.     Which amendment discusses guns? (2nd)
4.     In 2008, what did the Supreme Court decide? (that it is a constitutional right to have a loaded hand gun at home for self defense)
5.     Did this affect federal or state laws? (federal)
6.     What did the 2010 ruling decide about this? (that is applies both to state and federal)
7.     What did the 1939 Supreme Court decision state? (that is about being in a militia (collective rights))
8.     What is the current interpretation of the 2nd Amendment? (individual rights)
9.     Can Americans carry legally owned guns from one state into another? (no)


US Civ
Discussion Questions
Week 4
The Incumbency Effect
1.     What is the conventional take on national elections? What is this called?
2.     How many Democrats and Republicans were in the House of Representatives when this article was written?
3.     Where do Democrats hold a lot of seats? Is it a problem for their re-election?
4.     How man incumbents defeated their challengers in 1994?
5.     Where does the term “incumbency effect” come from?
6.     Where is it seen most clearly?
7.     Name 3 reasons why it’s easier for incumbents to get elected.
8.     Name 3 reasons why the democratic incumbents might not win.
9.     Do people feel in general that their representatives are “in touch” with their state?
10.  Have Republicans persuaded voters that they can make a change by voting in the mid-term elections?

Friday, September 23, 2011

Quiz #1

You will have a quiz on your 5th class day (week 5). This quiz will cover all of the articles that you have read and the class discussions. There are 6 groups/sections of this class. Find your class below and the corresponding quiz day. The hour and room of your quiz WILL NOT change. Just come to class like you normally do and be prepared to take the quiz. We will stay and have discussion afterwards. If you have any questions, please email me.


Thursday 17h15 & Thursday 18h15 -- 6 October

Friday 12h15 & 13h15 & 15h15 -- 7 October

Wednesday 8h15 -- 12 October
 

The quiz cannot be rescheduled. If you miss it you will receive a zero.

Wednesday, September 21, 2011

Week 4 Reading and Assignment


Please read this article for week 4. Make sure you are reading the correct article! Count which week you are on. The reading for week 4 is what is to be read by the time you come to your 4th class. In addition to reading, please summarize this article (5-7 sentences) and turn it in to me at the end of the class. If you come to class without having read the article, I will ask you to leave and you will lost your attendance grade for the day. Participation and preparation are mandatory. If you have any questions, you must email me (megan.oprea@univ-montp3.fr). 

The 'Incumbency Effect' Isn't So Effective This Year
by Linton Weeks, October 25, 2010


The conventional take on national elections is: The candidate already in office nearly always wins. Political scientists call this "the Incumbency Effect." It's especially true in elections for the House of Representatives, which occur every two years. In the past 17 congressional elections — since 1976 — more than 90 percent of representatives in office have won re-election. But this year is looking different. And, for many Democratic incumbents, difficult.
In fact, political observers are questioning whether the incumbency seawall can hold against the so-called Republican Tsunami — forecast to sweep across the country in the midterm contests on Nov. 2 — next Tuesday. At present, there are 255 Democrats and 178 Republicans in the House. Gary C. Jacobson, a political science professor at the University of California, has been specializing in congressional elections for more than 30 years. The 2010 elections, he says, "will be a severe test of the incumbency advantage, because it is the only thing standing between Democrats and the Tsunami."
Aside from the troubled economy, Jacobson says, the main bugaboo for the incumbent Democrats "is that they hold so many seats in Republican-leaning districts." (…) When all of the votes are counted, 2010 may prove to be a complete reversal of 2006 and 2008, when Democrats, especially in the South and in conservative districts, won GOP seats because of dissatisfaction with Republicans. As The Washington Post has noted, 49 Democrats hold seats in districts that were carried by John McCain in 2008.
The upshot is that, especially for Democrats in the House, incumbency may be cumbersome.
A Bent Toward Incumbents
The Incumbency Effect is a truism. In 1994, for instance, when the "Republican revolution" swept through the land during President Bill Clinton's first term and the GOP took 52 seats, the turnover rate in the House was only 20 percent. As Stephen C. Erickson showed in his essay "The Entrenching of Incumbency: Re-elections in the U.S. House of Representatives, 1790-1994": "91.3 percent of all incumbents who ran in 1994 defeated their challengers."
The term "Incumbency Effect" is often traced back to an influential article in 1975 titled: "Name Familiarity, Reputation, and the Incumbency Effect in a Congressional Election" by Alan Abramowitz, a political science professor at Emory University. "The electoral advantage of incumbency is perhaps one of the best known and least understood facts of American political life," Abramowitz wrote. "Nowhere is the advantage of incumbency more clear than in elections for the U.S. House of Representatives."

From NPR's 'Election Scorecard'

In his study, Abramowitz pointed out the advantages that incumbents have over challengers. It's easier for incumbents to martial campaign resources, such as money, volunteers, group endorsements and party support. Incumbents get more frequent publicity than challengers. Incumbents enjoy "free" mail and communications with their constituents. Voters more often know the names and faces of people in office. (…)
But Abramowitz agrees that the Democrats are liable to lose a lot of seats because of a combination of normal midterm voting patterns that favor the opposition party, the Democrats' need to defend a large number of seats in Republican-leaning or marginal districts and a high level of discontent among the electorate. (…)

Lining Up Early To Vote
In late September, a Pew Research Center/National Journal poll showed that while only 13 percent of Americans surveyed gave Congress (the institution) positive grades, 28 percent gave their individual representatives good or excellent marks, and 43 percent felt that their representatives were "in touch" with their constituents. The same number, 43 percent, believed that the incumbent House member "can help bring about change in Washington," while only 32 percent said their representative "has been in Washington too long." And 42 percent of those surveyed said their incumbent representative "does a good job of bringing projects" to the home district. (…)
Wendy Schiller, a political science professor at Brown University, says the Incumbency Effect is almost always weakened in midterm years under unified government. One exception, she says, was 2002, when George W. Bush was president and Republicans gained four House seats. This year, with a Democratic president and Democratic control of the Senate and House, Schiller says, "the Republicans have done a good job of persuading voters that they can register their anger and make a change, so voters feel engaged and empowered. When voters believe that their votes will change the course of policy and even control of government, they line up early in the morning to vote."
Reflecting the findings of the Pew poll, Schiller says the Incumbency Effect is grounded in local constituency service. "In a year where national issues reign supreme," she says, "even the most diligent incumbent will be in danger of losing their seat."
Some incumbents use a more graceful exit strategy than losing. They retire. But "retirements are not unusually high" in the House this year, Gary Jacobson says. In fact, only 20 Democrats and 23 Republicans will ride off into the sunset — perhaps just ahead of a coming tsunami.

Thursday, September 15, 2011

Week 3 Reading and Assignment


Your assignment is to read the following article closely and carefully in order to be prepared for class discussion. Remember to understand the article but also to think about your own opinions and whether the article has influenced you one way or the other. Please also write a brief summary and reaction (7-10 sentences) to the article to be turned in at the end of class.

For three decades, the story of gun control was one of notorious crimes and laws passed in response, beginning with the federal law that followed the assassinations of Robert F. Kennedy and Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. in 1968. But after a Democratic-controlled Congress in 1994 passed bills proposed by President Clinton to restrict certain kinds of assault weapons and to create a national system of background checks for gun purchases, the political pendulum began to swing the other way. President Bush's defeat of Al Gore in the 2000 presidential election was attributed in part to the perception among gun owners that Mr. Gore was "anti-gun." […]
Recent battles have taken place in the courts, revolving around fundamentally differing interpretations of the oddly punctuated, often-debated Second Amendment, which reads: "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed."
The Supreme Court in 2008 embraced the view that the Second Amendment protects an individual right to own a gun for personal use, ruling 5 to 4 that there is a constitutional right to keep a loaded handgun at home for self-defense.
But the landmark ruling in District of Columbia v. Heller addressed only federal laws; it left open the question of whether Second Amendment rights protect gun owners from overreaching by state and local governments.
On June 28, 2010, the court ruled in another 5-4 decision that the Second Amendment restrains government's ability to significantly limit "the right to keep and bear arms." The case involved a challenge to Chicago's gun control law, regarded as among the strictest in the nation. Writing for the court, Justice Samuel Alito said that the Second Amendment right "applies equally to the federal government and the states."Read More...
The McDonald v. Chicago ruling is an enormous symbolic victory for supporters of gun rights, but its short-term practical impact is unclear. As in the Heller decision, the justices left for another day the question of just what kinds of gun control laws can be reconciled with Second Amendment protection.
A 1939 decision by the Supreme Court suggested, without explicitly deciding, that the Second Amendment right should be understood in connection with service in a militia. The "collective rights'' interpretation of the amendment became the dominant one, and formed the basis for the many laws restricting firearm ownership passed in the decades since. But many conservatives, and in recent years even some liberal legal scholars, have argued in favor of an "individual rights'' interpretation that would severely limit government's ability to regulate gun ownership.
In May 2009, President Obama signed into law a provision allowing visitors to national parks and refuges to carry loaded and concealed weapons. The amendment was added to a consumer-friendly credit card measure that the president has said is important.
The provision represents a Congressional victory that eluded gun rights advocates under a Republican president. But in July 2009, the Senate turned aside the latest attempt by gun advocates to expand the rights of gun owners, narrowly voting down a provision that would have allowed gun owners with valid permits from one state to carry concealed weapons in other states.
When President Obama took office, gun rights advocates sounded the alarm, warning that he intended to strip them of their arms and ammunition. But Mr. Obama has been largely silent on the issue while states are engaged in a new and largely successful push for expanded gun rights, even passing measures that have been rejected in the past.
Source : http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/subjects/g/gun_control/index.html